Some photos of red admirals (Vanessa atalanta) that we often see around the Beebe Lake/Botanic Garden area.
It’s been a long time since we simply posted about some of the butterflies we see around town rather than rearing notes of species we rear. We used to do so quite frequently back in Albany, California and when we first moved to Ithaca, but we haven’t as of late. But, today there happened to be a red admiral (Vanessa atalanta) flying near the Beebe Lake/Botanic Garden area that landed enough times to get some decent photos of. We’ve seen these quite frequently this summer around this area, along with Polygonius species (interrogationis, common, or progne?), crescents, and skippers, though we haven't really gotten a chance to photograph these since they are so small and quick.
We’ve always been very curious as to what the atalantas and Polygonius are utilizing as hosts here, because whatever it is it must be relatively common for us to be seeing the butterflies so frequently. Back at home, we also had a lot of atalantas and satyr commas (P. satyrus) which used stinging nettles (Urtica dioica) and invasive pellitory (Parietaria). We tried looking for plants in the nettle family (Urticaceae) around the areas here that we see the butterflies but never found any (though maybe we did but never knew since we aren’t really experts at identifying them). It would be great one day if we could find out what they are eating so we could look for larvae, but alas we seem to be in the dark as of now.
Alan Liang is a student at Cornell University in Ithaca, New York pursuing an undergraduate degree in entomology. He is co-owner and a main contributor of the Liang Insects blog and photographs.
A female western tiger swallowtail (Papilio rutulus) eclosed; stock originated from a single pairing between reared female and wild male in Albany, California, Summer 2017. We also captured a female eastern tiger swallowtail (Papilio glaucus) at Cornell Botanic Garden. This post makes a basic comparison between these two representatives of their respective species.
Today, we had a medium sized Papilio rutulus female eclose from pupae originating from Albany, California. We also happened to catch a Papilio glaucus female at at the Cornell Botanic Garden. This is the first time we have had live specimen of the two similar species side by side, so we took this as an easy opportunity to compare them. Additionally, since the geographic range of both these species is quite vast and significant regional variation in phenotype is expected, this comparison may offer insight for the California Bay Area and Upstate New York type localities.
Below, the rutulus female is shown to the left, the glaucus female in the middle, and the two species side by side to the right.
Granted, the glaucus female has been free to rome the wild for a while and therefore not as pristine as the rutulus, it does seem that the glaucus is a paler shade of yellow with much more pronounced win venation. The rutulus is a deep, rich shade of yellow, creating an overall yellower appearance, similar to another western species, P. multicaudata. Although the venation is less pronounced in the rutulus, as well as some of the internal black stripe patterning, the black bordering the wings seems to be thicker proportional to the total wing area. Like the other rutulus females we have seen, there is a slightly visible yellow stripe running between the black border of the forewing, which contributes to making the black appear thicker. These elements make the rutulus appear "cleaner".
Interestingly, neither of the pictured individuals have much blue. This is interesting, at least for the glaucus, since glaucus females are known to have more blue coloration than other "tiger" species, with one hypothesis for this being that the dark form evolved to have more blue coloration to be better mimics of Battus philenor and that the yellow form retains this trait (reference). The dark form does not seem to be common in Ithaca and B. philenor is not present here. Additionally, the pictured female is quite small and small individuals tend to have less blue coloration proportional to total wing area, perhaps because blue is a costly color to produce and small size correlates with poor larval diet. Similarly, the rutulus female is smaller than the other females that eclosed this year from the same progeny and these other females have a bit more blue. Another thought is that the glaucus in Upstate New York are similar to P. canadensis, which is smaller than glaucus and lacks extensive blue coloration. They fly sympatric to glaucus in some parts of this region and likely hybridize, but probably not here in Ithaca.
A point to make is that the glaucus has more of an orange coloration at the base of the hindwings rather than a reddish color, and the uppermost discal spot is orange rather than yellow. This orange spot is present in other eastern species like P. troilus and P. polyxenes but not in any of the western species that we know of. The role of this spot is unclear, especially because the area of the wing that it takes place is usually covered by the forewing when the butterfly is at rest. One possibility could be to mimic B. philenor (troilus and polyxenes are mimics, too), which has similar orange spots on its hindwings; however, these spots are limited to the underside of the hindwing and the mimicking species do also have orange coloration on the underside of their hindwings.
One last thing to note is that the glaucus has an overall much more convex wing shape whereas the rutulus is more concave. Both the forewings and hindwings of the glaucus are shorter, rounder, and less sharp at the ends. Although the swallowtail tail area of the glaucus are a bit torn, it does seem as though that the tails are also shorter than the rutulus's. These features make the rutulus appear more triangular. In addition, the chain of yellow spots along the wings are rounder in the glaucus, although both species likely can have both extremes of this trait.
Brian Liang is a student at Cornell University in Ithaca, New York pursuing an undergraduate degree in entomology. He is co-owner and a main contributor of the Liang Insects blog, insects articles, and site design.
The falls in Ithaca are very colorful.
It's mid October and the leaves here in Ithaca have been starting to change color and drop. As California natives, we had never known that fall could be so attractive and colorful, since back home, most trees were either evergreen or semi-evergreen, and any trees that did drop their leaves weren't very colorful. Here in Ithaca, however, virtually all the trees here are deciduous besides the conifers, creating a beautiful display of colorful leaves. Walking down the Cornell campus, there was a huge spectrum of colors from green, yellow, orange, to red. The reflection of the trees in the water of Beebe Lake was spectacular. The crabapple trees also have a very ornamental appearance now that their leaves have fallen but their fruit have not.
At this time of year, there doesn't seem to be many insects around anymore. All the more common ones (hymenopterans, dipterans, etc.) are still fairly common, but collecting has definitely become much harder even when the weather in warm and sunny. As far as leps, there aren't really any flying except cabbage whites, clouded and orange sulfurs, monarchs, and recently, painted ladies. There are still some small moths left as well.
Rearing notes for our giant swallowtail (Papilio cresphontes) fifth instar larva. Originally found as a second instar on rue (Ruta graveolens) in Ithaca, New York.
Rearing notes 9/2/17-9/7/17:
We have compiled documentation of a selected few butterfly species we have encounted so far in Ithaca, New York.
Things have been quite hectic since coming to Ithaca, New York so we have not had the time to properly document every species we encounter each day, nor have we been able to keep up with some of the things we have been doing with them. This post compiles a few random butterfly species that we collected over the past week because it would be pointless to make several smaller posts and because no pictures were ever taken for the majority of things we saw or caught.
Moving in chronological order that the pictures were taken, the first species is Papilio cresphontes. We have been seeing tons of these swallowtails; they are perhaps the most common butterfly after skipper species, cabbage whites, and monarchs. We were able to capture several females since coming to Ithaca, but none of them laid any eggs. About half of them died before we even got a real chance to set them up because they were already so worn down and weak when we caught them (almost none of them had a complete set of legs. . . ). The set up that we used consisted of rue cuttings in a laundry bag left outside in open sun. Females were fed as much as possible, but it was difficult to get them to fatten up when they were so skinny to begin with. After up to two or three days of zero reaction to the rue, we would give up on the female.
The second species here is monarch (Danaus plexippus). We didn't really know what to expect with these up here in the North, but as it turns out they don't seem to be any less common than back in Albany, California. In fact, they may be even more common at this time of year based on the fact that we are seeing them almost everyday, sometimes even around urban areas. An interesting thing to note is that the monarchs here definitely seem to be smaller in size than the ones back home.
Number three is the great spangled fritillary (Speyeria cybele). These are somewhat rare even though it would make sense that they would be flying strong right now, spilling the eggs right before it gets cold because the first instar larva in the overwintering stage. So far, we have already managed to catch two females. We had set the first one up in a tub with nothing in it, hoping that it would lay without any extra help because they supposedly quite careless about where they do it in the wild (by that I mean not necessarily laying on the host plant but if not, usually still in close proximity). Unfortunately, it did not lay at all and died after several days of starvation on the day that we finally found a source for violets (Viola) and brought some home. By this time, we had captured a second female that did lay an egg or two on the violet before losing all interest for no apparent reason other than it seemed to be getting weak. We blame this on our lack of patience initially in trying to get the butterflies to feed. We have found out the hard way that this species takes an awfully long time (sometime several minutes of struggling) to realize that there is food, even after we force the proboscis into honey-water. With any other species, we would automatically assume by the end of 30-60 seconds of resistance that the thing just isn't hungry.
On the same day and exact location (butterfly bush [Buddleja] at Cornell Botanic Garden) that we caught the first Speyeria, we also caught two American ladies (Vanessa virginiensis). Our initial thought was actually that we had painted ladies (Vanessa cardui), but these are much smaller and have much larger spots on the hindwings. This is our first time seeing virginiensis, even though they are also supposed to fly in Alameda County, California. So far, this is the only Vanessa species in Ithaca.
The last species that this post includes is the orange sulphur (Colias eurytheme). When we first got here and saw all these white butterflies dashing around the grassy, wildflower areas we almost puked thinking that the cabbage white (Pieris rapae) would still be the most common and boring species all the way across the country. As it turns out, most of them are indeed cabbages, but in certain areas, they are sulfurs (the sad part is that sulfurs are also supposed to be common on the west, but they are some of the rarest sights back at home where there are a tiny fraction of the number of insects compared to Ithaca). The most common habitat for these is on open, grassy fields (literally grass in this case) with little flowers. We sometimes see half a dozen C. philodice and occasionally C. eurytheme. There are usually both males and females there, including a few white form females like the one in the picture. The things fly incredibly fast and are impossible to catch even when landed because they are so sensitive to movement.
Although they are not pictures in this post, we thought it would be appropriate to discuss the endings of our female Papilio troilus and female Limenitis arthemis astyanax. We did not get spicebush (Lindera benzoin) until a week after capturing the female and by that time, the weather was not good for egg laying at all. We attempted to set it up, but we could not get any activity out of the female whatsoever even though it was extremely plump and still decently strong. Because spicebush cuttings dry out so fast, we were struggling to keep up the setup and eventually, we tried bringing her to the live plants at Mundy Wildflower Garden and putting her in a laundry bag, but there was still no sun at all. After a while, it became apparent that she was still not at all interested in laying. It was just as well, then, that we accidentally let her get away. As for the Limenitis, we never got around to making a very good setup because we lack host plants (we also don't know what host plants they really like here) and the first one we caught got away after the laundry bag it was in got knocked over sometime during the afternoon that we were out collecting. The second female we caught was almost dead when we caught it so we never got a chance at all with her.
Today we found a whopping three dozen giant swallowtail (Papilio cresphontes) eggs scattered among several rue (Ruta graveolens) plants at the Cornell Botanic Gardens.
It has been two days since we last visited the Cornell Botanic Gardens. We spent the weekend exploring other locations, thinking that we might have better luck finding new things since we have already been to the gardens many times since coming to Ithaca. When we came back for a brief checkup late this afternoon, we didn't really have high hopes for finding much, especially because it was not sunny and it had not been sunny in the previous days either.
We were thoroughly surprised when we found several rue (Ruta graveolens) plants that were clobbered in Papilio cresphontes eggs. Almost all of them look to fresh, and because we check the plants carefully every time we have ever been to the garden, it was quite apparent that some female(s) for some reason just decided to let herself go and spilled everything. This pattern of abrupt egg laying, while probably holds true to some extent in many swallowtails and other species, is actually quite interesting based on our experience with female cresphontes. The things don't emerge with a single matured egg in them (after that it seem to take ages to build the eggs up) and when skinny wild-caught females are put to work, they never lay or show any behavior indicating a desire to lay. In the wild, the females probably nectar for many days before they finally decide to fulfill their duty, which can explain what we saw. It just so happens that there weren't that many rue plants and the plants themselves are very small (relative to tree hosts), both of which are ideal conditions to seal the deal for finding eggs in large numbers. Keep in mind that although we alone have seen or captured several females over multiple days in this area and the cresphontes flight is at a peak at this time of year in New York, this is our first time in ten days of looking that we have seen something like this.
The eggs were consistently laid at the periphery of the plant, much like P. zelicaon and parsley (Petroselinum) (which has very similarly shaped leaves as rue). Also, most of the eggs seem to be laid on the bottom half of the plant, in what can be considered more hidden locations. Every single one was laid on the upper side of the leaf, which is typical of swallowtails. Like Battus philenor eggs, the grainy substance on the cresphontes eggs doesn't seem to give them a very good stick (at least on rue leaves) because a lot of the eggs fell off as or after they were collected.
Rearing notes for our giant swallowtail (Papilio cresphontes) larvae. Originally found as larvae on rue (Ruta graveolens) in Ithaca, New York.
Rearing notes 8/22/17-8/26/17:
After locating rue (Ruta graveolens) at the Cornell Botanic Gardens, we were able to find eastern giant swallowtail (Papilio cresphontes) larvae.
After our first trip to the Cornell Botanic Garden yesterday, we realized that many butterflies such as Papilio cresphontes and troilus are common and still in flight here. Thus, on our visit today, we tried to locate some of their hosts in order for to attempt getting eggs out of the females we caught yesterday, and also to find any larvae or eggs that might be on them.
At first, we spent a long time trying to find troilus hosts, spicebush (Lindera benzoin) and sassafras (Sassafras albidum), but we simply couldn't (makes us wonder why the butterfly was even here??). We later asked one of the workers there who told us there wasn't spicebush in this section of the garden, but there was some in the arboretum, but that was far from here and a storm was due in half an hour.
We then quickly moved on to searching hosts of the Rutaceaea feeding cresphontes. We knew there was some lemon trees (Citrus limon) there, but they were small and not very good, so there wasn't much hope of finding eggs or larvae on it. Instead, we tried looking for hop (Ptelea trifoliata), prickly ash (Zanthoxylum americanum), or rue (Ruta graveolens). Based on the Botanic Garden plant database, there was no prickly ash and the few hop trees they were supposed to have were apparently in a different section quite far from where we were looking. We thus forgot about the hop and prickly ash and tried to find some rue, which they supposedly had three patches of in the herb section.
After searching for probably much longer than we should've (half an hour at least?), we located two of the three patches, which in retrospect were actually just in plain sight. We quickly scanned the first patch, but surprisingly found no eggs or larvae, despite that the butterflies (both sexes) were always flying around the garden (while we were searching, we actually caught a male cresphontes drinking nectar, though we have little use of him). When we got to the second patch, we were delighted to see that there was a second instar sitting right in front of us on the upper side of a leaf. We eagerly searched the pants for more, but all we could find was a dead second instar on a leaf (no idea what the case of mortality was). The single live larva was good enough for us though - we had never seen the larvae of this or related Heraclides group species in real life until now. The larva is a perfect dropping mimic (much more convincing than other Papilio larvae we have seen), being shiny with blotches of white on the dorsum of the abdomen and rear. The thorax is also extremely enlarged and shaped like a snake head. We collected the larva in a dish and started heading back as the storm was beginning.
While looking for the cresphontes and troilus hosts, we spotted a bunch of the common stuff again, like melanoplus and band-winged grasshoppers, monarchs, skippers, red-spotted purples, etc. There were also a terrifying amount of Heminoptera and Diptera here compared to at home, with probably hundreds (thousands?) swarming the flower bushes in the garden.
We also took a few shots of the garden right before we left if you were wondering how it looked.
Today we checked out Cornell University's botanic garden in Ithaca, New York for the first time and ended up collected a several new butterflies.
Yesterday, we hiked around Beebe Lake, which is right next to and should lead to the Cornell botanic garden, but we never actually made it there because it was late and we were tired. This afternoon, we set out again, taking to the road instead of the Beebe trail, which is a much more efficient route.
Our first impression of the garden was that there were tons and tons of good butterfly nectar flowers. When we first stepped inside to walk around, we were greeted immediately by a large black swallowtail sucking from bunches of pink flowers under a tulip tree (Liriodendron tulipifera). Our first thought was a black form female eastern tiger swallowtail (Papilio glaucus) (the tulip tree was reassuring) or possibly a black swallowtail (P. polyxenes asterius). However, neither of those sound likely because P. glaucus is early season univoltine (possibly second partial) in upstate New York and we cannot find any egg or larvae of P. polyxenes despite the presence of numerous species of host plants (some exotics in an edible state). Spicebush swallowtail (P. troilus) never even crossed our mind at the time not just because it is a species that we have never had any experience dealing with in the past and know very little about, but also because we have yet to find any host plants around (even in the garden). It was not until we caught it with a laundry bag and got a close look at it that we realized that it was indeed P. troilus—and a surprisingly fresh and plump female at that.
It has very wide and rounded fore- and hindwings with white and gray spots (not yellow) that are surprisingly large (no smaller than your typical western tiger [Papilio rutulus]) because we have always been under the impression that P. troilus is a small species. Unlike tigers, there is very little blue except on the back of the hindwings and there are two very distinct rows of orange spots there instead of one. The ovipositar is white, which coincidentally or not, corresponds with the color of the eggs. The head shape is also sort of strange. . . unexplainably.
Inside the garden, there are a lot of butterfly bushes (Buddleja) that were covered in butterflies from skippers (mostly silver-spotted [Epargyreus clarus] and some least [Ancyloxypha numitor]), some monarchs (Danaus plexippus) (we see these often in the urban areas too, so evidently they are quite common), and--to our great surprise--giant swallowtails (Papilio cresphontes). There were at least three of these humongous butterflies sucking from the butterfly bushes that we tried pouncing on several times with the laundry bag before catching a very fat female. We were surprised because we expected the giants to be quite rare up here in the Northern range and because, like the P. troilus, we could not find any host plants growing wildly anywhere. Rue (Ruta graveolens) and hop tree (Ptelea trifoliata) are supposedly at the garden, but we could not find the rue and the hop tree is in a completely different section, far from the butterflies we saw. The only thing we could find at the garden were two potted Citrus, but they were in bad shape and did not have any egg or larvae on them.
After we got home and took a closer look at our catch, we measured a whopping ~130 mm, making it larger than any butterfly we have ever seen except two-tailed (P. multicaudata) (it is larger than any P. cresphontes or rumiko we have obtained from pupae). The ovipositar is orange, which again corresponds with the color of the eggs.
In the same area as the giants, we found white admirals (Limenitis arthemis arthemis), which is something brand new to us. From a distance, the things have a strong resemblance to the pipevine swallowtail (Battus philenor) (and the other mimics) and because of its large size, we almost mistook it for another P. troilus when we first saw them. We snagged one as it was sucking and it too turned out to be plump female. These are supposed to eat Prunus spp. and willow (Salix). There is very little Prunus around here (none in the garden), and none of it is native cherry (Prunus pennsylvanica or serotina) which should be preferred; the only willows are a few Salix nigra on the edge of Beebe Lake. For now, yet another mystery. . .
Around 5 '0 clock, it started to rain a bit and the butterflies scurried away, so we headed home. It was certainly too late to start trying to get them to lay eggs. And, as mentioned before, a major issue is that we don't really have good (if any at all) host plants for them and, even if we did have access to them, it would have to be cuttings. On top of that, the laundry bag would make a very meager setup. We will definitely need to check the garden again soon or explore elsewhere to try to gather the host plants and to collect more butterflies to increase our chances of getting eggs. For now we are keeping the butterflies locked up in darkness and feeding them honey that we quickly purchased at the convenience store.
Ithaca, New York
This timeline is a series of daily posts recording our observations and experiences with various insects around the Cornell University campus in Ithaca, New York, starting from the time we moved here in 2017. As this is a personal blog, we try to keep collections for our entomology course work to a minimum, and mainly focus on just the species we catch and raise for our own fun and interest. Posts prior to this time can be viewed at Timeline 2012-2017: Albany, California.
July 2019 (26)
June 2019 (46)
May 2019 (20)
March 2019 (1)
January 2019 (1)
September 2018 (1)*
August 2018 (9)*
July 2018 (11)*
June 2018 (22*)
May 2018 (18)*
April 2018 (2)*
January 2018 (6)
December 2017 (5)
November 2017 (1)
October 2017 (5)
September 2017 (26)
August 2017 (19)
*Currently, a significant portion of 2018 posts are missing. The notes/photos for this time period are saved on our personal files but the posts were never built due to a busy schedule that year. We are still actively building these posts when we have the time.
Full Species List
(Alphabetical by scientific name)
Battus philenor hirsuta
Liminitis arthemis arthemis
Limenitis arthemis astyanax
Papilio polyxenes asterius
Papilio polyxenes asterius × Papilio zelicaon
Full Species List
(Alphabetical by scientific name)
Butterflies & Moths
Common checkerspot skipper
Eastern tiger swallowtail
Great spangled fritillary
Milkweed tussock moth
Salt marsh moth
Virginia creeper sphinx
Western tiger swallowtail
White-marked tussock moth
Wild indigo duskywing
Butterfly & Moth Hybrids
Black swallowtail × anise swallowtail
Grasshoppers, Katydids, & Crickets
Carolina band-winged grasshopper
Lesser meadow katydid
Sword-bearing conehead katydid
Two-spotted tree cricket
Cascadilla Gorge Trail
Cornell Botanic Gardens
Mundy Wildflower Garden
Albany, California Updates